Whistlin' and Crowin' Response

It's surprising to me how much Sohn reaffirms stereotypes for men.  The only good man in this entire book is Jean's husband who is crippled and has to rely on her for support.  Although it does well to break women's stereotypes from this region.  These women accomplish things against all odds to support their family. They are all saintly women. I do like how Sohn has had all of these women in her class as students, it really brings a better perspective on how well she knows each woman.  I think Sohn really stresses how hard working the people of Appalachia are.  How the people of this area really have a dedication to their family and to provide for loved ones.  She also does a good job at showing the neighborliness of these women and the people surrounding them.  Although again she does a poor job in general of showing anything good about the male population.